Sun Xiaoguo Case

Sun Xiaoguo Case: The Death-Row Inmate Who Walked Free, Then Was Executed in 2020

I. Overview of the Core Facts of the Case

Sun Xiaoguo, formerly known by the names Chen Guo and Li Linchen, male, Han ethnicity, a native of Kunming, Yunnan Province. His true date of birth was October 27, 1977, but because he had not reached the age for enlistment, his stepfather Li Qiaozhong, using the convenience of his position as deputy director of the Police Affairs Division of the Headquarters of the Yunnan Border Defense Corps of the Armed Police, changed his date of birth to October 27, 1975.

The court found upon retrial that Sun Xiaoguo’s criminal trajectory spanned more than twenty years, with core nodes including: in 1994 he was convicted of rape and sentenced but was not actually taken into custody; in 1997, while on medical parole, he committed multiple serious crimes including rape, compelling insult of women, intentional injury, and picking quarrels and provoking trouble; in 1998 he was sentenced to death at first instance, later changed on appeal to death with a two-year reprieve, then changed on retrial to twenty years’ fixed-term imprisonment, and released in 2010 after multiple sentence reductions; after release he organized and led a gang-like criminal organization, committing crimes including running gambling houses, picking quarrels and provoking trouble, illegal detention, and intentional injury; in July 2018 he kicked and ruptured another person’s bladder at a KTV, which triggered a comprehensive review of the case; in 2019 the retrial upheld the death sentence, and in February 2020 the death penalty was executed.

II. The First Crime and Escape from Custody: 1994 to 1997

(I) The 1994 Rape Case and Illegal Medical Parole

In 1994, Sun Xiaoguo was sentenced at first instance by the Panlong District People’s Court of Kunming to three years’ fixed-term imprisonment for rape. During the handling of the case, his parents helped Sun Xiaoguo obtain release on bail pending trial and medical parole illegally by forging medical records, so that after the judgment took effect Sun Xiaoguo was not taken into custody to serve his sentence; the unserved term was two years, four months, and twelve days.

This link was the direct precondition for the series of crimes Sun Xiaoguo subsequently committed. The retrial judgment confirmed that precisely because of the illegal medical parole, Sun Xiaoguo remained in a state of de facto personal freedom for a long period after the 1994 judgment.

(II) Serious Crimes During Medical Parole in 1997

During the period when he was not taken into custody to serve his sentence, Sun Xiaoguo’s crimes escalated sharply. The facts found on retrial by the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court are as follows:

Rape: From April to June 1997, Sun Xiaoguo raped four minor girls by violence and coercion, one of whom was a young girl (attempted). The retrial judgment specifically enumerated multiple aggravating circumstances of the rape crime: raping multiple women, abducting and raping in a public place, illegally restricting victims’ personal freedom, raping in public, raping minors, committing another crime during the execution of a sentence, and being a repeat offender of rape. According to disclosures by the responsible person of the Yunnan High People’s Court in answering reporters’ questions, the four victims included one 17-year-old and two 15-year-old minor girls, as well as one young girl under 14.

Compelling insult of women and intentional injury: On November 7, 1997, Sun Xiaoguo and accomplices seized two 17-year-old girls in a public place, inflicting violent injury and humiliating abuse on them, causing one victim serious injury. The retrial judgment’s assessment was that “the criminal means were extremely brutal and outrageous.”

Picking quarrels and provoking trouble: On July 13 and October 22, 1997, Sun Xiaoguo and others wantonly chased, intercepted, and beat others in public places, causing three victims to be injured.

III. The 1998 Death Sentence and the Subsequent “Reversal”

(I) First-Instance Death Sentence

In February 1998, the Kunming Intermediate People’s Court, at first instance, combined the punishments for Sun Xiaoguo’s multiple crimes and decided to execute the death penalty with deprivation of political rights for life. The specific penalties found at first instance were: death for rape; fifteen years’ imprisonment for compelling insult of women; seven years’ imprisonment for intentional injury; three years’ imprisonment for picking quarrels and provoking trouble; combined with the unserved term of two years, four months, and twelve days for the 1994 rape, the decision was to execute the death penalty.

(II) Second-Instance Change to Death with Reprieve

In March 1999, the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court made a second-instance judgment changing Sun Xiaoguo’s death sentence to death with a two-year reprieve. According to the Yunnan High People’s Court’s later explanation after the retrial sentencing, the key reason for the second-instance change was “denying the first instance’s finding of the fact that Sun Xiaoguo raped a young girl and changing the sentence on that basis,” while the retrial review held that this denial “was inconsistent with the facts ascertained in this retrial and involved errors in finding facts and applying law.”

(III) Retrial Change to Fixed-Term Imprisonment

In September 2007, the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court made a retrial judgment further changing Sun Xiaoguo’s penalty from death with reprieve to twenty years’ fixed-term imprisonment. This series of “reversals” from death to death with reprieve and then to fixed-term imprisonment constituted the core question that later drew national attention to the Sun Xiaoguo case: how could a criminal sentenced to death at first instance, in less than ten years, have his penalty reduced to twenty years’ fixed-term imprisonment through judicial proceedings.

(IV) Sentence Reductions and Release

After the twenty-year fixed-term sentence took effect, Sun Xiaoguo received multiple sentence reductions during his imprisonment. On April 11, 2010, Sun Xiaoguo was released upon completion of his sentence. From the first-instance death sentence in 1998 to his actual release, his actual time served was twelve years and five months. After release, Sun Xiaoguo operated in Kunming under the name “Li Linchen,” successively serving as a shareholder of Yunnan Mitu Investment Management Co., Ltd., Yunnan Yinhe Investment Co., Ltd., and Kunming Xiji Trading Co., Ltd., as well as a shareholder or actual controller of the former Kunming Kundu M2 Bar and several other bars.

IV. Gang-Related Crimes After Release and the 2018 KTV Case

(I) Organizing and Leading a Gang-Like Criminal Organization

The court later found that between 2013 and 2018 Sun Xiaoguo committed the crimes of organizing and leading a gang-like criminal organization, running gambling houses, picking quarrels and provoking trouble, illegal detention, intentional injury, obstructing testimony, and bribery. His gang formed a certain degree of illegal control in Kunming’s nightlife sector. The criminal facts of this stage were the basis for the later first-instance judgment of the Yuxi Intermediate People’s Court.

(II) The July 2018 KTV Intentional Injury Case

On the evening of July 21, 2018, several flight attendants from a Yunnan airline were drinking and singing at a KTV in Kunming. While intoxicated, flight attendant Li had a dispute with male colleague Wang; Li told him not to leave and then made a phone call. Soon, a group of tattooed people rushed into the KTV, and the leading man was Sun Xiaoguo. Sun Xiaoguo raised his leg and kicked Wang hard in the abdomen, rupturing his bladder on the spot, causing Wang serious injury of the second degree, while others were injured to varying degrees. After the attack, Sun Xiaoguo walked away as if nothing had happened.

After the incident, the Guandu Branch of the Kunming Public Security Bureau opened an investigation on July 30, 2018, and on August 30 released Sun Xiaoguo on bail pending trial. After the case was transferred to the Guandu District People’s Court on January 3, 2019, the handling authorities discovered that Sun Xiaoguo was the criminal sentenced to death at first instance in 1998. This discovery became the starting point of the turning point in the entire case.

V. Comprehensive Review and Retrial of the Case

(I) Trigger Mechanism

In March 2019, when the Panlong District People’s Court of Kunming was handling this KTV intentional injury case, the three characters “Sun Xiaoguo” aroused the vigilance of the staff. Zhu Binbin, deputy secretary of the Political and Legal Affairs Commission of the Kunming Municipal Party Committee, later recalled in a special documentary: “When I saw this name, my first reaction was, how did he get out? Wasn’t he originally sentenced to death? How did he get out again, and commit another crime?”

On March 18, 2019, the Guandu District People’s Court decided to arrest Sun Xiaoguo. Public security organs immediately launched a comprehensive investigation into suspected illegal and criminal activities after his release upon completion of sentence in 2010, discovering that Sun Xiaoguo and his gang members had in an organized manner successively carried out illegal and criminal activities including affray, running gambling houses, picking quarrels and provoking trouble, and illegal detention, suspected of gang-related criminal activity.

(II) Supervision and Initiation of Retrial

In April 2019, the 20th Central Supervision Group for the Campaign Against Gang Crimes entered Yunnan and listed the Sun Xiaoguo case as the No. 1 supervised case, jointly investigating the truth of the case with the Yunnan Provincial Office for the Campaign Against Gang Crimes. Zhang Li, deputy head of the supervision group, later stated: “We locked it in as the No. 1 major case for supervision. At the beginning, we also doubted how he could get through so many links one step at a time and reach the point he did later—this was simply unimaginable to us.”

On July 26, 2019, the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court decided in accordance with law to initiate a retrial of the case in which Sun Xiaoguo committed rape, compelling insult of women, intentional injury, and picking quarrels and provoking trouble in 1997. On October 14, 2019, the Yunnan High People’s Court held a retrial hearing in accordance with the trial supervision procedure.

(III) Ascertainment of the “Network of Connections” and “Protective Umbrellas”

The special task force investigation found that behind Sun Xiaoguo’s repeated escapes from the net of law was the “network of connections” woven over many years by his mother Sun Heyu and stepfather Li Qiaozhong. Sun Heyu had originally been a police officer of the Guandu Branch of the Kunming Public Security Bureau, and had been sentenced in accordance with law in 1998 and dismissed from public office for helping Sun Xiaoguo forge materials to obtain release on bail pending trial. From first instance to second instance to appeal, retrial, and execution of penalty, multiple links were breached layer by layer. On December 15, 2019, the duty crime cases of 19 public officials and important related persons involved in the Sun Xiaoguo case were publicly sentenced.

VI. Retrial Judgment and Execution

(I) Retrial Sentencing

On December 23, 2019, the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court publicly pronounced judgment in accordance with law in the Sun Xiaoguo retrial. The judgment held that the original retrial judgment made by the court in September 2007 and the second-instance judgment made in March 1999 were indeed erroneous in the conviction and sentencing of Sun Xiaoguo, revoked them in accordance with law, and upheld the February 1998 first-instance judgment of the Kunming Intermediate People’s Court sentencing Sun Xiaoguo to death.

At the same time, the crimes committed by Sun Xiaoguo after release, including organizing and leading a gang-like criminal organization, were sentenced at first instance by the Yuxi Intermediate People’s Court to twenty-five years’ fixed-term imprisonment, and the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court upheld the sentence on appeal. The retrial judgment combined the death sentence with the twenty-five years’ fixed-term imprisonment for the new crimes, and decided to execute the death penalty on Sun Xiaoguo, with deprivation of political rights for life and confiscation of all personal property.

In its reasoning for the judgment, the Yunnan High People’s Court stated: Sun Xiaoguo “ignored national law, committed crimes repeatedly, with extremely cruel criminal means, extremely serious criminal circumstances, extremely vile social impact, extremely great social harm, extremely deep subjective malice, and extremely great personal danger, and was a criminal of the most heinous kind.”

(II) Death Penalty Review and Execution

Upon review, the Supreme People’s Court issued a ruling on February 12, 2020, approving the criminal judgment of the Yunnan Provincial High People’s Court deciding to execute Sun Xiaoguo. The Supreme People’s Court held upon review that in his rape crimes Sun Xiaoguo had particularly serious circumstances or aggravating circumstances such as raping multiple women, raping a young girl, abducting in a public place, raping minor females, illegally restricting personal freedom, committing rape in public, and being a repeat offender of rape, and that “the criminal means were extremely cruel, the criminal circumstances extremely vile, the criminal consequences extremely serious, the subjective malice extremely deep, and the personal danger extremely great.”

On February 20, 2020, in accordance with the execution order issued by the Supreme People’s Court, the Kunming Intermediate People’s Court of Yunnan Province executed Sun Xiaoguo. Before execution, the court arranged in accordance with law for Sun Xiaoguo to meet his close relatives.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *