I. Overview of the Core Facts of the Case
Yu Huaying, female, born in 1963, from Yunnan. After trial, the court ascertained that between 1993 and 2003, Yu Huaying, in order to seek illegal benefits, separately colluded with her husband Wang Jiawen, her lover Gong Xianliang, and others, moving across Guizhou Province, Chongqing Municipality, Yunnan Province, and other places to commit crimes, trafficking a total of seventeen children. Most of these children were trafficked thousands of miles away to Handan, Hebei.
Zhao Hongbo, deputy chief judge of the First Criminal Trial Division of the Guizhou Provincial Higher People’s Court, commented in a disclosure after the case concluded: “Her crimes were not acts of impulse. Over a period of ten years, she moved from place to place committing crimes in a premeditated and organized manner.”
Yu Huaying’s path of child trafficking began with selling her own biological child. According to CCTV reports, she gave birth to a baby boy while cohabiting with Gong Xianliang. Because both had families and were unable to raise the child, they sold the child to Handan, Hebei, for several thousand yuan. This act was later traced back as the starting point of her child-trafficking criminal career.
II. Methods of Crime and Target Selection
(I) Targeting Children Lacking Supervision
According to reports from multiple media outlets, the targets Yu Huaying targeted when committing crimes were mostly children whose parents were busy making a living and whose homes lacked supervision. Her crime locations were concentrated near stations, around street vendors, and similar places in Duyun, Guiyang, and other areas of Guizhou. These areas were crowded with people, and parents often could not watch their children at all times because they were making a living.
(II) Using Neighborly Relations to Approach Targets
When committing crimes in Guiyang, Yu Huaying adopted a more concealed method: she rented a place next door to the target family, first built neighborly trust, and then waited for an opportunity to strike. In 1995, Yang Niuhua’s family moved from Zhijin County, Bijie, Guizhou, to Guiyang, and Yu Huaying subsequently moved in next door to their home, abducting Yang Niuhua while her parents were not paying attention. This method shows that Yu Huaying’s crimes were not random encounters but premeditated acts with a certain period of observation and preparation.
(III) Using Children to Lure Children
In Duyun, the way Chen Binglian’s younger son was abducted was even simpler and more direct: while the older son was playing nearby with the younger son, Yu Huaying used an ice pop to lure the younger son away. Exploiting young children’s low vigilance toward strangers and desire for food was one of the methods by which Yu Huaying succeeded many times.
(IV) Abducting Two Children from the Same Family at Once
One detail disclosed during the court trial was particularly striking: there were 5 families from which Yu Huaying abducted two children at once. In 1996, Luo Xingzhen of Duyun ran a stall near a long-distance bus station, and her two children, Hua Lan and Hua Bai, were abducted by Yu Huaying. For more than twenty years afterward, Luo Xingzhen kept guarding that shoe-repair stall, hoping her children would return to the place they had once known and find her. She said in an interview: “Because my children were lost, and it was in this place, I have never left here.”
III. Key Victim: Yang Niuhua and the Uncovering of the Case
(I) Abducted in 1995
Yang Niuhua, born in 1990, was only 5 years old when she was abducted. In 1995, in order to create better living conditions for her and her older sister, her parents moved from Zhijin County to Guiyang City. Shortly after Yu Huaying moved in next door, she abducted Yang Niuhua while her parents were off guard.
(II) Memories from the Course of Abduction
Yang Niuhua’s memories of the abduction process became key evidence later used to identify Yu Huaying. She recalled that Yu Huaying took her “from car to train, from train to car again” to an unfamiliar place. On the way, because young Yang Niuhua had wet her pants, she was beaten by Yu Huaying. Yang Niuhua’s description at the trial was extremely specific: “As soon as she saw that my pants were wet, she started kicking me. When she kicked me, in the end she grabbed me by the hair and lifted me up, so that is how I remembered her appearance.”
This memory, etched into her since the age of five, became the direct driving force more than twenty years later that brought Yu Huaying to court.
(III) Reporting the Case and Arrest in 2022
After growing up, Yang Niuhua relied on her memory of Yu Huaying’s appearance, gathered evidence, and reported the case to the police, providing criminal clues about her own trafficking. In June 2022, Yu Huaying was captured by police in Chongqing Municipality. From Yang Niuhua’s abduction in 1995 to Yu Huaying’s capture in 2022, twenty-seven years had passed.
IV. The Development of Judicial Proceedings and the Gradual Clarification of Criminal Facts
(I) Original First Instance: 11 Children, Death Penalty
On September 18, 2023, the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court issued a first-instance judgment in the Yu Huaying case, finding that she had trafficked 11 children and sentencing her to death with deprivation of political rights for life. Fan Hongbin, chief judge of the First Criminal Trial Division of the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court, explained the basis for the judgment afterward: “Through our review of the evidence, we believed the evidence was indeed sufficient, and considering her subjective malice and social harmfulness, our unanimous opinion was to impose the death penalty.”
Yu Huaying appealed in court.
(II) A Turning Point During the Second Instance: Her Husband’s Capture Led to Omitted Crimes
After Yu Huaying appealed, the case entered second-instance proceedings. During the second instance, a key variable emerged: Yu Huaying’s husband, Wang Jiawen, was captured. Wang Jiawen’s confession revealed other trafficking crimes he had committed jointly with Yu Huaying, facts that had not been pursued in the original trial.
Shi Weican, deputy chief judge of the Third Criminal Trial Division of the Guizhou Provincial Higher People’s Court, stated: “In the second instance, new criminal facts were discovered, so it was decided in accordance with law to remand the case to the Guiyang Intermediate Court for retrial.”
On January 8, 2024, the Guizhou Provincial Higher People’s Court ruled to remand Yu Huaying’s child-trafficking case for retrial.
(III) The Substantive Significance of the Remand for Retrial
At the time of the remand, Yu Huaying had already been sentenced to the maximum penalty of death in the original trial. To the outside world, this procedural action might raise the question of whether the sentencing was in doubt, but that was not the consideration of the judicial authorities. Ma Li, deputy chief judge of the First Criminal Trial Division of the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court, explained: “The purpose of remanding for retrial is to exhaust all means to investigate all of Yu Huaying’s criminal facts clearly, to make this case clear and completely transparent, and to ensure that the lawful rights of all trafficked families can be protected.”
In other words, the purpose of the retrial was not to reconsider whether the death penalty should be imposed, but, on the basis of the death sentence, to clarify every criminal fact, confirm the identity of every trafficked child, and incorporate the demands of every victim family into judicial findings.
(IV) Retrial First Instance: 17 Children, Death Penalty Again
On October 11, 2024, the retrial first instance of the case opened at the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court. The number of children the prosecuting authority accused Yu Huaying of trafficking increased from 11 in the original trial to 17, with 6 newly added trafficked children involving 4 incidents.
On October 25, 2024, the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court announced the retrial first-instance judgment. The court again found that Yu Huaying’s criminal circumstances were especially serious and the social harm extremely great, and sentenced her to death for the crime of child trafficking, deprived her of political rights for life, and ordered confiscation of all her personal property. Yu Huaying stated in court that she would appeal.
(V) Retrial Second Instance: Final Instance Upholds Original Judgment
On December 19, 2024, the Guizhou Provincial Higher People’s Court opened the retrial second-instance hearing in Yu Huaying’s child-trafficking case. The Guizhou Higher Court ruled in court to reject Yu Huaying’s appeal and uphold the first-instance death sentence. This ruling was the final ruling, and Yu Huaying could not appeal again. According to CCTV reports, the Guizhou Higher Court ultimately found that Yu Huaying had trafficked 17 children, causing the separation of flesh and blood in 12 families.
From her capture in June 2022 to the final ruling in December 2024, Yu Huaying appeared in court six times and was sentenced to death twice.
V. The Protracted Trauma of the Victim Families
While the judicial proceedings in the case advanced, the stories of multiple victim families entered public view through media reports. The experiences of these families constitute concrete footnotes to the consequences of Yu Huaying’s crimes.
Luo Xingzhen, the shoe-repair stall owner near the Duyun long-distance bus station. After her two children were abducted in 1996, she chose to remain in the same place, making a living from the shoe-repair stall, and did not leave for more than twenty years. “Because my children were lost, and it was in this place, I have never left here.”
Chen Binglian, also running a stall in Duyun. After her younger son was lured away by Yu Huaying with an ice pop, she and her husband raised their older son while searching for the younger son. On the long road of searching for their child, Chen Binglian’s husband passed away with regret, never having waited for any result.
Yang Niuhua, who more than twenty years after being trafficked personally brought Yu Huaying to court. At the trial, she said to Yu Huaying: “Yu Huaying, do you still recognize me? Your name is Yu Huaying. I remembered it for a full 26 years. I have always remembered it.”
The common feature of these families is that the abductions occurred in scenes of daily life—beside stations, next to stalls, at the doorsteps of homes—and what Yu Huaying exploited was precisely the gap when parents were busy making a living and could not provide full-time supervision. This pattern of crime was repeatedly carried out over a period of ten years, spanning multiple places in Guizhou, Chongqing, and Yunnan, until it was terminated in 2022 because of Yang Niuhua’s report.
VI. Judgment Result
On February 28, 2025, with the approval of the Supreme People’s Court, the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court of Guizhou Province executed Yu Huaying in accordance with legal procedures, and the procuratorial organ dispatched personnel on site for supervision in accordance with law. Before execution, the court arranged for Yu Huaying to meet with close relatives.
The Supreme People’s Court, upon review, confirmed the criminal facts that Yu Huaying, between 1993 and 2003, colluded with others to traffic seventeen children, and approved the death sentence handed down by the Guiyang Intermediate People’s Court on October 25, 2024. The procedure in which the Guizhou Provincial Higher People’s Court rejected the appeal and upheld the original judgment in its second-instance ruling was also confirmed upon review.